Science & Regulation · Quality Control
Essential Oil Chromatography: Chiral GC and ISO Standards
Key facts
- The ISO catalogue lists, under committee ISO/TC 54, documents on sampling, physical constants, chemical values and chromatographic analysis of essential oils.
- European Pharmacopoeia monograph 02098, “Essential oils”, has the status “In use”, and two revisions of it are recorded as on-going.
- In a 2021 study, none of eleven commercial oils labelled P. sylvestris was classified as P. sylvestris by the authors’ model.
- The same authors conclude that chiral analysis of pine oils gives additional information on their authenticity.
- In a 2023 rose oil study, the authors propose that current ISO norms for the genuineness of R. damascena oil are insufficient.
In the ISO catalogue, ISO 7609:1985 is titled “Essential oils — Analysis by gas chromatography on capillary columns — General method”. ISO 22972:2004 is titled “Essential oils — Analysis by gas chromatography on chiral capillary columns — General method”. Allenspach et al. (2021) analysed pine oils, and Raeber et al. (2023) rose oils, by GC-FID on a DB-wax column and on a chiral cyclodextrin column.
Which plants and which oils do the studies cover?
According to the World Checklist of Vascular Plants (WCVP, Kew), in an extract read on 3 November 2026, Pinus sylvestris L. has rank “Species” and status “Accepted”, in the family Pinaceae (identifier 380126). In the same extract, Rosa × damascena Herrm. has rank “Species” and status “Artificial Hybrid”, in the family Rosaceae (identifier 2968261). Its accepted-name column points to that same identifier, 2968261. Raeber et al. (2023) write the name “Rosa damascena”, abbreviated “R. damascena”, without a taxon author.
Allenspach et al. (2021) bought eleven commercial essential oils labelled “P. sylvestris” (n = 11, numbered 1 to 11) from different suppliers. They also bought two turpentine oils (n = 2, numbered 12 and 13) from different suppliers. Their primary oils came from Pinus sylvestris L. (n = 27, numbered 14 to 40) and from Pinus cembra L. (n = 6, numbered 41 to 46). Further primary oils came from Pinus mugo Turra, written “Pinus mugo TURRA” (n = 8, numbered 47 to 54), and from Pinus nigra J.F.Arnold, written “J. F. ARNOLD” (n = 5, numbered 55 to 59).
Raeber et al. (2023) analysed a total of 10 rose oil samples, which they call “authentic”, by GC-FID on the DB-wax column and on the chiral column. These “authentic” rose oils and the other essential oils of the study were bought in Swiss pharmacies and online. All samples were stored at room temperature, in brown glass vials.
How are the oils analysed by gas chromatography?
According to the review by Sadgrove et al. (2022), a mass spectrometer coupled to a gas chromatograph is called gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC-MS). The review names two primary diagnostic methods for identifying essential oil components; the first is the “fingerprint”, the pattern of fragments produced by the mass spectrometer. According to the review by Sadgrove et al. (2022), the second diagnostic method used in gas chromatography is the arithmetic index (AI), also known as the retention index. Because retention time differs between instruments and methods, it is standardised as a relative index calculated with a homologous series of n-alkanes, injected onto the GC-MS column under exactly the same operating conditions as the essential oil.
Allenspach et al. (2021) ran a conventional GC-FID analysis on a DB-wax capillary column and a chiral GC-FID analysis on a BGB 176 SE capillary column. Raeber et al. (2023) ran a polar GC-FID analysis on a DB-wax capillary column and a chiral GC-FID analysis on a BGB 178 30 % CD capillary column. The table gives the conditions as each study reports them; the two studies are not averaged.
| Study and column | Length × i.d., film | Injector | Injection and split | Carrier gas | Oven programme | Detector |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allenspach et al. (2021), DB-wax | 30 m × 0.25 mm, 0.25 μm | 220 °C | 1 μl; split ratio 1:50 (split flow 75 ml/min) | helium, constant flow 1.5 ml/min | 65 °C for 10 min, then 5 °C/min to 220 °C, held 9 min | 250 °C |
| Allenspach et al. (2021), BGB 176 SE (chiral) | 30 m × 0.25 mm, 0.25 μm | 220 °C | 1 μl (commercial oils) or 2 μl (primary oils); split ratio 1:70 (split flow 28 ml/min) | helium, constant flow 2.5 ml/min | 50 °C for 3 min, then 2 °C/min to 200 °C | 250 °C |
| Raeber et al. (2023), DB-wax | 30 m × 0.25 mm, 0.25 μm | 220 °C | 1 μL; split ratio 1:50 (split flow 100 mL/min; gas safe flow 20 mL/min) | helium 6.0, constant flow 2.0 mL/min | 45 °C for 15 min, then 5 °C/min to 220 °C, held another 9 min | 250 °C |
| Raeber et al. (2023), BGB 178 30 % CD (chiral) | 25 m × 0.25 mm, 0.25 μm | 250 °C | 1 μL; split ratio 1:60 (split flow 140 mL/min; gas safe flow 20 mL/min) | helium 6.0, constant pressure 100 kPa | 60 °C for 2 min, then 2 °C/min to 180 °C, held another 3 min | 260 °C |
In the pine study, the chiral column consists of 30 % 2,3-dimethyl-6-tert-butyldimethylsilyl-β-cyclodextrin dissolved in SE-52 (5 % phenyl-, 95 % methylpolysiloxane). In the rose study, the chiral column consists of 30 % “2,6-diethyl-6-tert-butyldimethylsilyl-beta-cyclodextrin” dissolved in a combination of 15 % phenyl- and 85 % methylpolysiloxane.
Allenspach et al. (2021) analysed primary oils diluted in heptane and commercial oils diluted ten-fold in heptane. Their results are relative percentages of the individual components, based on the FID response (peak area). On the chiral column, peaks were identified by comparing their retention times with reference substances.
How was the method for Rosa × damascena oils validated?
Raeber et al. (2023) validated their own analytical method according to the ICH Q2(R2) guidelines. Six calibration standards (Cal) and three quality control samples (QChigh, QCmed, QClow) were prepared by serial dilution of separate stock solutions in n-heptane. Cis-3-hexen-1-ol was added to each Cal and QC as internal standard, at a final concentration of 10 mM. For accuracy and precision, Cal and QC samples were analysed on 5 separate days over 2 weeks, the QC samples in duplicate.
Accuracy was expressed as a bias, and intra-day and inter-day imprecision as relative standard deviations (RSDR and RSDT). The retention index (RI) was determined with a homologous series of n-alkanes (C8–C20, C21–C40) and calculated by the van den Dool and Kratz equation. Peak resolution (Rs) was determined according to the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) 11.2. Limits of detection (LoD) and quantification (LoQ) were calculated from the standard deviation of the response and the slope of the calibration curve.
Each row gives a validation result as the source reports it.
| Column | Parameter | Result as reported |
|---|---|---|
| DB-wax | Separation, all analytes | baseline separation, Rs > 2.4, total run time 60 min |
| DB-wax | LoD and LoQ, all analytes | LoD 0.96 to 4.55 ng; LoQ 2.90 to 13.78 ng |
| DB-wax | % bias at the lower and upper calibration range, all target analytes (abstract) | lower: −7.8 to 13.2 %; upper: −13.1 to 5.2 % |
| DB-wax | RSDR and RSDT of the QChigh, QCmed and QClow control samples | did not exceed ± 20 %; QC stability observed over the 14-day validation, variation within a 20 % deviation limit |
| Chiral | Separation | “baseline separation”, Rs > 0.7 |
| Chiral | % bias at the lower and upper calibration range, all target analytes (abstract) | lower: 0.5 to 13.3 %; upper: −6.9 to 7.0 % |
| Chiral | LoD, all analytes | 0.03 to 1.28 ng |
On the chiral column, the authors note that, according to the Gaussian distribution, an Rs of 0.7 leads to a peak overlap of around 8 %. Complete peak separation is “expected” at Rs values above 1.5; “therefore”, in their words, not all analytes achieved complete separation.
On the DB-wax column, selectivity was demonstrated by spiking rose, lavender, rosemary, lemon and caraway oils. Spiked rose oils showed a good recovery, with deviations below 20 %, and most analytes showed excellent recovery, with a few exceptions. For example, the limonene spiked into lemon oil was overestimated, which “might” be due to spiked concentrations much lower than the limonene occurring in lemon oil.
On the chiral column, the spiking experiments gave results similar to those on the DB-wax column, the recovery deviation (RE) not exceeding 20 %. Recovery was excellent for spiked rose oils, while oils from other species gave “mixed results”. QChigh and QClow concentrations spiked into “authentic” rose oil also gave an RE below 20 % for all analytes.
What does gas chromatography show in commercial and primary Pinus oils?
In Allenspach et al. (2021), all the commercial oils fulfilled the Ph. Eur. criteria for “pine sylvestris oil”. They were composed mainly of monoterpene hydrocarbons, with α-pinene as the dominant analyte. Their sesquiterpene pattern differed significantly from that of the primary oils of the corresponding species. According to the authors, a possible reason “could have been” a modification of the primary oils, for example by rectification.
Although labelled P. sylvestris, none of the commercial oils was classified as P. sylvestris by the authors’ PLS-DA model. Six remained unclassified, and the model assigned five to the predicted class P. nigra. After adding the chiral information of α-pinene to the 39 existing variables, with a fourth-root preprocessing, an unsupervised principal component analysis (PCA) was sufficient to uncover patterns in the GC-FID chromatograms. In this data set, a three-dimensional PCA gave a clear taxonomic separation between primary and commercial oils, and between primary oils of different pines, on three components explaining 70.2 % of the total variance.
The PCA also revealed a chemical similarity between the commercial oils and the turpentine oils. The authors write that this emphasises a “possible dilution” with turpentine-oil-based substances.
In their conclusion, the authors write that the GC-FID chromatographic profile is able to distinguish primary from commercial pine oils. They add that the lack of sesquiterpene patterns in the further treated commercial oils “might be explained” by rectification. In their view, chiral analysis provides additional significant information on the authenticity of pine oils. It allows, they write, to uncover “possible” mislabelling, the use of wrong herbal substances or adulteration within the supply chain.
What does the chiral analysis of α-pinene show in oils labelled P. sylvestris?
In Allenspach et al. (2021), the α-pinene enantiomers were baseline separated, with a resolution Rs = 2.1. In the commercial and primary oils, α-pinene was present in both enantiomeric forms (+/−). For the chiral analysis, 20 μl of each oil were diluted with heptane to 10 ml. The enantiomeric excess (ee, %) was calculated from peak areas: (area of predominant enantiomer − area of minor enantiomer) / (area of predominant enantiomer + area of minor enantiomer) × 100.
Table 1 of the study gives, for the eleven commercial oils, the ee of (−)-α-pinene as mean ± standard deviation (n = 3), with the class predicted by the PLS-DA model.
| Commercial oil | Class predicted by the model | ee of (−)-α-pinene (%) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | P. nigra | 3.1 ± 0.0 |
| 2 | not classified | 19.8 ± 0.0 |
| 3 | not classified | 78.4 ± 0.1 |
| 4 | P. nigra | 76.0 ± 0.0 |
| 5 | not classified | 74.3 ± 0.0 |
| 6 | not classified | 82.4 ± 0.0 |
| 7 | not classified | 69.1 ± 0.0 |
| 8 | P. nigra | 76.1 ± 0.1 |
| 9 | P. nigra | 66.7 ± 0.1 |
| 10 | P. nigra | 8.6 ± 0.1 |
| 11 | not classified | 83.0 ± 0.0 |
In P. sylvestris oils of different origins, the dominant enantiomer was (+)-α-pinene. Only three samples, written “P. silvestris”, showed a minor excess of (−)-α-pinene. P. cembra showed the same dominant enantiomer as P. sylvestris, (+)-α-pinene. (−)-α-pinene was predominant in P. nigra, in P. mugo and in the turpentine oils analysed.
The commercial oils fell into two groups by their ee of (−)-α-pinene: most belonged to group 1 (65.0–85.0 %), the second group ranging from 0.0 to 20.0 %. According to the authors’ data, a threshold of, for example, 17.5 % ee for (−)-α-pinene “would allow” identification of a commercial essential oil (specificity 1.0; sensitivity 0.82). For the authors, a possible reason for the high ee of (−)-α-pinene in the commercial oils “could have been” an intended or unintended confusion in the raw material.
What does chiral analysis show in Rosa × damascena oils?
According to the abstract of Raeber et al. (2023), the chiral analysis separated the enantiomers (+/−)-camphene, (+/−)-rose oxide, (+/−)-linalool, (+/−)-citronellol and (+/−)-citronellyl acetate. It also separated the diastereomers of citral and of β-damascenone. Pure reference compounds for the isomers were not commercially available, and no literature RI values existed on chiral GC columns. The authors therefore chose a semi-quantitative approach comparing enantiomeric excess (EE) and diastereomeric excess (DE), without identifying the compounds.
These EE and DE determinations showed either that one stereoisomer was present or that one of the two appeared dominantly. (−)-rose oxide “predominantly” appeared in the “authentic” R. damascena samples. Rose oil sample number 1 contained only (+)-rose oxide, which, the authors write, “might be an indication of adulteration”. For citronellyl acetate, only one isomer form “seems” to appear in R. damascena samples, and for β-damascenone a single isomer was “mostly” observed.
The authors compared the quantification results of the two methods with Bland–Altman plots, for six major compounds that were not separable stereoisomers. Almost all measurements fell within the 95 % limits of agreement. The authors conclude that the quantification gave “equal values” for these analytes with both methods. Their conclusion states that ten “authentic” rose oil samples were fully quantified by both methods.
Mass spectra of reference compounds were compared with those of the “authentic” rose oil samples, to exclude “possible” interferences with other compounds that “might” elute at the same time. The results are coherent with the polar GC-FID analysis. With GC-MS, β-damascenone was “not detected in any of the samples”, which contradicts the polar GC-FID analysis and agrees with the chiral GC-FID analysis. Sensitivity, LoD and LoQ were not determined for the GC-MS analysis.
According to the authors, the GC-FID methods performed similarly to GC-MS in unambiguously identifying and discriminating the selected analytes. They propose that combining RI-based retention times from a chiral and a polar GC-FID analysis “can” give similar identification results, while being cost-effective, robust and practical. In their conclusion, determining the enantiomeric ratio “can” be a useful tool for authenticity and originality testing. They also propose that current ISO norms qualifying the genuineness of R. damascena oil are insufficient and “can” be easily evaded.
How were the primary Pinus oils obtained?
In Allenspach et al. (2021), the primary oils of P. sylvestris were obtained from needles and twigs, freshly cut into 1 cm pieces, by “industrial distillation”. The plant material was classified by macroscopic botanical identification. The primary oils of P. cembra, P. mugo and P. nigra were obtained from the same plant parts, cut the same way, also by “industrial distillation”.
Which ISO documents of committee ISO/TC 54 does the catalogue list?
Each row below is an entry of the ISO catalogue for classification ICS 71.100.60, as read in a web archive copy of 19 March 2026. Titles and stage codes are reproduced as the catalogue writes them; the content of the documents is not reproduced here.
| Reference | Title | Stage | Committee |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISO 210:2023 | “Essential oils — General requirements and guidelines for packaging, conditioning and storage” | 60.60 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 211:2023 | “Essential oils — General requirements for labelling and marking of containers” | 60.60 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 212:2007 | “Essential oils — Sampling” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 212:2007/Amd 1:2012 | “Essential oils — Sampling — Amendment 1” | 60.60 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 279:1998 | “Essential oils — Determination of relative density at 20 °C — Reference method” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 280:1998 | “Essential oils — Determination of refractive index” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 356:1996 | “Essential oils — Preparation of test samples” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 592:1998 | “Essential oils — Determination of optical rotation” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 709:2001 | “Essential oils — Determination of ester value” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 875:1999 | “Essential oils — Evaluation of miscibility in ethanol” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 1041:1973 | “Essential oils — Determination of freezing point” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 1241:1996 | “Essential oils — Determination of ester values, before and after acetylation, and evaluation of the contents of free and total alcohols” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 1242:2023 | “Essential oils — Determination of acid value by two titration methods, manual and automatic” | 60.60 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 1271:1983 | “Essential oils — Determination of carbonyl value — Free hydroxylamine method” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 1272:2000 | “Essential oils — Determination of content of phenols” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 1279:1996 | “Essential oils — Determination of carbonyl value — Potentiometric methods using hydroxylammonium chloride” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 3218:2014 | “Essential oils — Principles of nomenclature” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 3794:1976 | “Essential oils (containing tertiary alcohols) — Estimation of free alcohols content by determination of ester value after acetylation” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 4715:1978 | “Essential oils — Quantitative evaluation of residue on evaporation” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 4720:2018 | “Essential oils — Nomenclature” | 90.92 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 7359:1985 | “Essential oils — Analysis by gas chromatography on packed columns — General method” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 7609:1985 | “Essential oils — Analysis by gas chromatography on capillary columns — General method” | 90.92 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 7660:1983 | “Essential oils — Determination of ester value of oils containing difficult-to-saponify esters” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 8432:1987 | “Essential oils — Analysis by high performance liquid chromatography — General method” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 9235:2021 | “Aromatic natural raw materials — Vocabulary” | 60.60 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO/TR 11018:1997 | “Essential oils — General guidance on the determination of flashpoint” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 11021:1999 | “Essential oils — Determination of water content — Karl Fischer method” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 11024-1:1998 | “Essential oils — General guidance on chromatographic profiles — Part 1: Preparation of chromatographic profiles for presentation in standards” | 90.92 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 11024-2:1998 | “Essential oils — General guidance on chromatographic profiles — Part 2: Utilization of chromatographic profiles of samples of essential oils” | 90.92 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 14714:2024 | “Essential oils and aromatic extracts — Determination of benzene content” | 60.60 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 17494:2001 | “Aromatic extracts, flavouring and perfuming compounds — Determination of ethanol content — Gas chromatographic method on packed and capillary columns” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 18321:2015 | “Essential oils — Determination of peroxide value” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO/TR 21092:2004 | “Essential oils — Characterization” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO 22972:2004 | “Essential oils — Analysis by gas chromatography on chiral capillary columns — General method” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
| ISO/TS 24106:2021 | “Essential oils — Name harmonization of components” | 90.93 | ISO/TC 54 |
What does the European Pharmacopoeia record for its “Essential oils” monograph?
In the European Pharmacopoeia knowledge database (EDQM), consulted on 2 October 2026, monograph number 02098 has the status “In use”. The legend of the record defines “in use” as a monograph published in the European Pharmacopoeia, and “elaboration” as one under elaboration and not yet published. The monograph’s titles are “Essential oils” in English, “Huiles essentielles” in French and “Aetherolea” in Latin. According to the same legend, these are the titles currently approved by the European Pharmacopoeia Commission, and they “may” differ from the titles currently published.
The record’s Pharmeuropa field reads “32.2”; the legend defines it as the issue of Pharmeuropa in which the draft of the monograph was published. The monograph was last published in “10.7”, in English as in French.
The record lists two revisions of the monograph as “On-going”.
| Revision | State of work | Description | Pharmeuropa field |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | “1 - Draft” | “Revision to clarify requirements regarding the herbal starting material” | empty |
| 2 | “1 - Draft” | “Revision chromatographic profile” | empty |
In the legend, state “1” means “Draft work has started”, on a scale running from 0 (monograph authorised, work not started) to 4 (“DEF”, monograph adopted).
See also: Analytical chemistry of essential oils, EU cosmetics regulation, Toxicology of essential oils.
References
- Allenspach M., Valder C., Flamm D., Steuer C., « Authenticity control of pine sylvestris essential oil by chiral gas chromatographic analysis of α-pinene », Scientific Reports 2021;11:16923, doi:10.1038/s41598-021-96356-x — https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8376981/fullTextXML
- EDQM, European Pharmacopoeia, monograph details 02098 « Essential oils » (Aetherolea), consulted 02/10/2026 — https://extranet.edqm.eu/4DLink1/4DCGI/Web_View/mono/2098
- International Organization for Standardization (ISO), online catalogue, ICS 71.100.60 « Essential oils », archived copy of 19/03/2026 (Internet Archive) — https://web.archive.org/web/20260319152944id_/https://www.iso.org/ics/71.100.60/x/
- Govaerts R. (ed.), World Checklist of Vascular Plants (WCVP), Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew — https://sftp.kew.org/pub/data-repositories/WCVP/wcvp.zip
- Raeber J., Favrod S., Steuer C., « Determination of Major, Minor and Chiral Components as Quality and Authenticity Markers of Rosa damascena Oil by GC-FID », Plants 2023;12(3):506, doi:10.3390/plants12030506 — https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC9921129/fullTextXML
- Sadgrove N.J., Padilla-González G.F., Phumthum M., « Fundamental Chemistry of Essential Oils and Volatile Organic Compounds, Methods of Analysis and Authentication », Plants (Basel) 2022;11(6):789, doi:10.3390/plants11060789 — https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8955314/fullTextXML